Add range loop syntax:
- runtime for start..end (i) { } counting loop, cursor optional, end exclusive
- comptime inline for start..end (i) { } comptime-unrolled body
The inline form binds the cursor as an int_val comptime constant per
iteration, so xs[i] over a heterogeneous pack substitutes the concrete
per-position element -- the canonical's pack-iteration vehicle
(inline for 0..sources.len (i) { sources[i].addListener(...) }).
- AST: ForExpr.range_end, ForExpr.is_inline
- parser: parseForExpr range vs collection form; suppress_call flag so
N (i) is not read as a call N(i) while parsing a range bound
- lower: lowerRuntimeRangeFor / lowerInlineRangeFor; evalComptimeInt;
comptimeIndexOf extends pack-index resolution beyond int literals
Revises spec's inline for i in 0..N to the no-in, range-first, paren-cursor
form. Regression: examples/200-for-range.sx.
`xs.T` projects each pack element's protocol type-arg into a type list, usable
in TYPE/signature positions:
- tuple type `(..xs.T)` → e.g. `(s64, string)` (new resolveTupleTypeWithBindings)
- closure sig `Closure(..xs.T) -> R` → e.g. `Closure(s64, s64) -> s64`, which
contextually types a closure literal (resolveClosureTypeWithBindings now
expands a protocol pack via packTypeArgs).
Wired `tuple_type_expr` into `resolveTypeWithBindings` (type_bridge's tuple
resolver is stateless — can't see packs). `packTypeArgs(pack_name, projection)`
is shared: bare `..xs` → element types (`pack_arg_types`); `..xs.T` → each
element's `impl Box(args) for elem` target_arg (`elementProtocolTypeArg` scans
`param_impl_map`). In type position `xs.T` parses as a dotted `type_expr`, so
packTypeElems splits on '.'. examples/199-pack-type-projection.sx.
This completes 2.3's core: all spread/projection forms — call-arg, tuple value,
tuple type, closure sig — now lower. The canonical's `Closure(..sources.T)` /
`mapper(..sources.value)` / `(..sources)` shapes are functional.
A `spread_expr` element inside a tuple literal now expands the pack into the
tuple's fields: `(..xs.get)` ≈ `(xs[0].get(), …, xs[N-1].get())` (Decision 2 —
a pack is stored by materializing a tuple). lowerTupleLiteral detects a
pack-spread element via packSpreadRefs and splices the per-element Refs as
fields (typed via getRefType); for Box(T) the materialized tuple is
heterogeneous. A spread whose operand isn't a pack falls through to the
existing spread_expr diagnostic (tuple-value spread not yet handled).
When any element is a spread, field-count ≠ element-count, so the contextual
target-tuple alignment is skipped (field types inferred from the expanded refs).
examples/198-pack-tuple-materialize.sx.
A pack spread in call-arg position now expands to N positional args:
`add2(..xs.get)` ≈ `add2(xs[0].get(), xs[1].get())` — the canonical's
`mapper(..sources.value)` shape. The call-arg loop detects a spread whose
operand is a pack (`..xs`) or a pack projection (`..xs.method`) and splices the
per-element Refs in; a runtime-slice spread (`..arr`) is still left to the
slice-variadic path.
Factored the per-element synthesis out of lowerPackValueProjection into
`lowerPackElems` (used by both projection-to-tuple and spread-to-args), plus a
`packSpreadRefs` helper. examples/197-pack-spread-call.sx (2- and 3-arg, mixed
element types).
`xs.<method>` over a constrained pack projects a (zero-arg) protocol method
across every element into a tuple: `xs.get` ≈ `(xs[0].get(), …, xs[N-1].get())`.
lowerFieldAccess intercepts `xs.<m>` on a pack base (where <m> is a protocol
method) and synthesizes/lowers `xs[i].<m>()` per element into a tuple_init.
For a parameterised `Box(T)` the projected tuple is heterogeneous (each element
returns its own T). examples/196-pack-value-projection.sx.
Surfaced and fixed a pre-existing bug: inferExprType didn't handle tuple field
access (`t.0` / `t.x`), so a mixed-size tuple like `(42, "hi")` inferred the
string field as s64 — the wrong type then drove a bad `print` pack mangle and
coerced the string to i64 (garbage). Added the tuple arm (numeric + named).
Regression: a `(s64, string)` case in examples/190-tuple-values.sx.
A protocol-constrained pack element exposes only the constraint protocol's
interface (the locked decision): `xs[i].<member>` is rejected unless `<member>`
is one of the protocol's methods. `xs[i].v` (a concrete field of IntCell, not
declared on Box) now errors, like a constrained generic — even though the
substituted element is concretely an IntCell.
monomorphizePackFn records the pack param's constraint protocol in a new
`pack_constraint` map (pack-name → protocol); lowerFieldAccess checks it on an
`xs[i]` (index_expr) base BEFORE substitution erases the "constrained to P"
context. Protocol method calls (`xs[i].get()`) pass — the name is in the
protocol. Regression: examples/195-pack-interface-only.sx.
`xs[i].get()` on a parameterised `..xs: Box(T)` pack now resolves — the
canonical `ValueListenable` shape. registerParamImpl, for a CONCRETE-struct
source, now also registers the impl's methods as `<Source>.<method>` in
fn_ast_map (like a non-parameterised impl), so UFCS finds them. Such methods
are already fully concrete (`impl Box(s64) for IntCell` → `get(self: *IntCell)
-> s64`), so there's nothing to monomorphize; generic/pack sources stay lazy in
param_impl_map. First impl wins on a name collision.
Heterogeneous parameterised packs work: each `xs[i]` binds a different T and
dispatches to its own impl. Regression:
examples/194-protocol-pack-parameterized.sx (Box(s64) IntCell + Box(string)
StrCell, order-independent).
Calling a protocol method on a pack element now works: `xs[i].greet()` on a
`..xs: Greeter` pack dispatches to the concrete element's impl, and elements
may be heterogeneous (Dog, Cat). This is the protocol-interface access the
pack is for. (Protocol method decls omit the implicit `self`; impls list it —
the earlier malformed `(self: *Self)` decls were why dispatch looked broken.)
Also fixes packArgConformsTo for non-parameterised protocols: it queried
`protocol_thunk_map`, which is only populated lazily when a protocol VALUE is
built with `xx`, so it false-negatived valid conformers. Now it queries
impl-declaration state directly — `param_impl_map` for parameterised protocols,
or `<ty>.<method>` entries in `fn_ast_map` for non-parameterised ones.
examples/193-protocol-pack-methods.sx (heterogeneous Dog+Cat pack, per-element
greet(), order-independent).
Each argument bound to a `..xs: P` pack must conform to P — previously the
constraint was decorative (any type was accepted). `lowerPackFnCall` now
captures the pack param's constraint protocol and checks each pack arg via a
new `packArgConformsTo`, which accepts: a plain-protocol impl
(`protocol_thunk_map`), any parameterised impl `P(<args>) for T` (scan of
`param_impl_map` for a `P\x00…\x00mangle(T)` key — the per-element type-args
are inferred from the impl, not written out), or an arg already erased to P's
own protocol struct. Non-conformers get a per-position error pointing at the
argument. Only enforced for a known protocol constraint.
Regression: examples/192-pack-non-conform.sx (a struct lacking `impl Show` in a
`..xs: Show` pack → diagnostic, exit 1).
Design decision: a protocol-constrained pack element is viewed THROUGH the
constraint protocol — only the protocol's interface (its methods, and the
projections xs.T / xs.value) is accessible, not arbitrary concrete members,
exactly like a constrained generic `T: Show`. So `xs[i].v` (a field on the
concrete IntBox, not declared on Show) is an error; the constraint is enforced
and bounds the body regardless of the concrete arg types at a call site.
The previous example 191 demonstrated `xs[i].v` — which only compiled because
the constraint is not yet enforced. Trimmed it to the protocol-agnostic part
that's correct today (per-shape binding + comptime `xs.len` across arities /
heterogeneous shapes); protocol-interface access + projection are the remaining
2.4 work. specs.md records the access rule.
`..xs: Protocol` now binds like the comptime `..$args` pack instead of
falling through to a runtime `[]Protocol` slice: each call site
monomorphizes with the concrete per-position arg types, and `xs[i]` is the
concrete element via AST substitution (Decision 1 — a pack is a comptime
mechanism, no runtime pack value). So `xs[i]`'s own fields/methods dispatch
statically and elements may be heterogeneous, while `xs.len` is a comptime
constant.
Mechanism: one `isPackParam(p) = is_variadic and (is_comptime or is_pack)`
predicate replaces the four `is_variadic and is_comptime` pack-detection
sites (call-arg split, mangle, arg lowering, monomorphizePackFn), and the
early call dispatch routes any `isPackFn` call to `lowerPackFnCall` before
the `hasComptimeParams` gate (which is false for a protocol pack).
examples/191-protocol-pack.sx exercises N=0, N=2, concrete field access, and
a heterogeneous IntBox+StrBox pack. Conformance checking and projection
(`xs.T` / `xs.value`) are the remaining 2.4 work.
Pack/tuple spread now parses in tuple-value `(..xs)` / `(..xs.field)`,
tuple-type `(..F(Ts))` / `(..F(Ts.Arg))`, call-arg `f(..xs)` (already),
and closure-sig `Closure(..Ts)` / `Closure(..sources.T)` positions.
Design: the uniform spread node is the existing `spread_expr` (its
operand sub-expression carries the projection `xs.field` and
type-application `F(Ts)` shapes) rather than a new PackExpansion node —
call-arg slice-spread (`..arr`) and pack-spread (`..pack`) are
syntactically identical, so they must share one node, and spread_expr
already serves it with working slice lowering. Closure-sig packs gain
`ClosureTypeExpr.pack_projection` alongside the existing `pack_name`.
Parser-only; sema/lowering land in Phase 2. 6 new parser unit tests +
examples/probes/pack-expansion-parses.sx. Build + 225-suite green.
`..xs: Protocol` (a bare protocol, no `[]`, no `$`) on a variadic
parameter now parses to `ast.Param.is_pack = true` — a heterogeneous
protocol-constrained pack, distinct from a slice variadic
(`..xs: []T`, is_pack=false) and the comptime type-pack (`..$args`,
is_comptime=true). Parser-only: sema/lowering for the pack form land in
Phase 2; existing forms are unaffected (zero examples used a bare
non-slice variadic annotation). Adds three parser unit tests and
examples/probes/pack-param-parses.sx.
A tuple_init's element values must match its field types exactly — LLVM
`insertvalue` does no implicit conversion. An inferred `pair := (40, 2)`
lowered its elements under the enclosing fn's `target_type` (e.g. main's
s32 return), producing i32 values, while the field types were inferred
independently as s64. The {i64,i64} aggregate was filled with i32
constants, so reading any element back returned garbage (40 + 2^32) and
tuple equality was always false.
lowerTupleLiteral now lowers each element under its resolved field type
(the contextual target tuple's fields when present, else per-element
inference) and coerces to it, so value width always matches field width.
Assignment to a tuple-typed field/element now also propagates the target
tuple type. Adds examples/190-tuple-values.sx as a regression test and
examples/probes/tuple-baseline.sx as the Step 0.4 audit artifact.
`appendObjcEncoding` previously bailed on `.@"struct"`, which blocked
sx-defined `#objc_class` methods from declaring CGPoint / CGRect /
NSRange-shape signatures — the `class_addMethod` registration path
would emit a "type kind not yet supported by Obj-C encoding"
diagnostic. The helper now emits Apple's `{Name=field0field1...}`
form recursively, with a small `ObjcEncodingStack` (cap 16) that
breaks transitive struct→struct cycles by emitting the abbreviated
`{Name}` form instead of recursing forever.
`{Point=dd}`, `{_NSRange=QQ}`, `{CGRect={CGPoint=dd}{CGSize=dd}}`
all flow through the existing `objc_msg_send` + `class_addMethod`
path with no further plumbing.
Tests:
- `lower.test.zig` gains four cases: optional unwrap (single + nested),
flat struct (CGPoint, NSRange shape), nested struct (CGRect with
CGPoint+CGSize), bringing the helper's test coverage from
primitives + pointers to the full encoding table.
- `examples/ffi-objc-defined-class-02-struct-encoding.sx` exercises
a sx-defined `SxMover` class with `goto(p: Point)` setter and
`here() -> Point` getter end-to-end on macOS; the IR snapshot
confirms `v@:{Point=dd}` and `{Point=dd}@:` land in
`OBJC_METH_VAR_TYPE_` constants wired to `class_addMethod`.
Checkpoint cleanup: the "Next step (M1.2 A.1 — type-encoding
derivation table)" header in CHECKPOINT-FFI.md was stale (A.1
shipped in 6cc016c; A.0–A.7 all done; commit list now linked).
The encoding table stays as reference material.
224/224 example tests pass; zig build test green.
Previously, `t : Type = f64` stored a boxed string carrying the literal
name "f64"; comparisons and `type_of`/`type_name` round-trips lost the
underlying TypeId. This switches `Type` to a runtime-representable Any
pair: `{ tag = .any.index() (meta-marker), value = TypeId.index() }`.
Mechanism:
- `const_type` emits a 16-byte Any aggregate via insertvalue.
- `TypeId.any` advertises 16 bytes / 8-byte alignment so structs that
embed `t: Type` size correctly under verifySizes.
- `lowerBinaryOp` folds `==`/`!=` between static type-refs to a
`const_bool`, and decomposes runtime Any-vs-Any compares via
`unbox_any` so LLVM doesn't see icmp on aggregates.
- `lowerMatch`'s `is_type_match` path unboxes Any-typed subjects to
the i64 type tag before the switch, so `case type:` etc. fire.
- `lowerRuntimeDispatchCall` (used by `case T: ... cast(t) val`) does
the same unbox for the type-tag arg.
- `type_of(val: Any)` rebuilds an Any with `{.any, tag_of(val)}` so
the result is itself a `Type` value, not a bare i64.
- `buildPackSliceValue` stops re-boxing const_type — the value is
already canonical Any.
- `__sx_type_names` now indexes by TypeId across the whole table
using the new `types.formatTypeName` (structural names for `*T`,
`[]T`, `[N]T`, `?T`, `Vector(N,T)`, function/closure/tuple) so
runtime `type_name(t)` works for compound types.
- `interp.zig`'s comptime `type_name` accepts either the bare
`.type_tag` Value or the Any-boxed aggregate it now sees.
- `scanDecls` registers `Vec4 :: Vector(4, f32)` style aliases in
`type_alias_map` (before the `fn_ast_map` check; `Vector` IS a
`#builtin` fn). Lets `Vec4` in expression position lower as
`const_type(<vector tid>)`.
- `isStaticTypeArg` becomes scope-aware: a name shadowed by a runtime
local is not static. `isStaticTypeRef` is the symmetric helper for
the eq fold.
- `inferExprType` returns `.any` for bare type names (identifier and
type_expr) so pack arg types are correct.
Side effect: `print("{}", Vec4)` now prints the structural name
`Vector(4,f32)` rather than the alias literal `Vec4` — 12-meta's
expectation updated. Aliases stay pointer-equal to their target
(`Vec4 == Vector(4, f32)` is true).
Tests:
- examples/189-type-all-interactions.sx: 12-section comprehensive
coverage — literal `==`, `type_of(value) == T`, `Type` var storage,
`type_name` (static + runtime), printing Type values, generic
dispatch via `$T: Type`, `identity($T, val)`, `Wrap($T)`, reflection
builtins (`size_of`, `align_of`, `field_count`, `type_eq`),
`..$args` pack walking, `Type` in struct field, compound type
literals (`*Point`, `[4]s32`, `[]bool`, `?f64`).
- examples/12-meta.sx: expected output updated to reflect structural
name for the Vec4 alias path.
- ffi-objc-call-06-sret-return.ir: regenerated to absorb the new
type-name strings now emitted globally.
223/223 examples pass.
Generic `Into(Block) for Closure(string) -> void` (step 5.2) emits
a trampoline whose `callconv(.c)` param type collapses through
`abiCoerceParamType`'s `string → ptr` heuristic — the libc
"char *" convention. The caller side (typed fn-pointer cast +
indirect call through `b.invoke`) keeps the full `{ptr, i64}`
slice. Result on AArch64: caller passes 16 bytes in x0+x1,
trampoline reads 8 bytes from x0 only, the slice len is lost or
mis-tracked, and the trampoline's `memcpy` from the half-formed
string segfaults.
`examples/188-block-string-arg.sx` pins the post-fix behaviour
("got: <hello>"). Today's run segfaults inside the trampoline's
first read. The next commit splits `abiCoerceParamType` into a
foreign-only path (extern decls keep the libc collapse) and a
preserve-slice path (sx-internal `callconv(.c)`).
`compile_error(msg)` raises a build-time diagnostic at the call site
with `msg` as the error text. The arg must be a string literal —
runtime expressions can't be reported as compile errors. Used by
builder fns to reject malformed pack shapes / arg combinations
cleanly instead of silently emitting wrong code.
Today: `unresolved 'compile_error'`. Expected (post-fix): focused
diagnostic with the literal message at the call site's span. The
next commit adds the lowering arm.
All six produce their target outputs cleanly today; renamed out of
the `issue-*` namespace per CLAUDE.md "Resolving an open issue":
| Old | New |
|----------------------|-------------------------------------------|
| issue-0032 | 181-impl-duplicate-same-file |
| issue-0041 | 182-compound-type-in-expression |
| issue-0042 | 183-type-alias-size-align |
| issue-0044 | 184-objc-defined-class-method-self |
| issue-0045 | 185-pack-fn-comptime-return |
| issue-0046 | 186-nested-comptime-return |
Comment headers tightened to feature-focused (drop the issue-NNNN
provenance — that's in git history now). Missing expected `.txt` /
`.exit` files captured for 0041 + 0042 (they were untracked because
the bugs were fixed silently in adjacent work).
`examples/issue-*` after this commit: just `issue-0030.sx` — a
feature request (`extern G : T;` cross-file globals) that's never
been implemented. Staying in the issue namespace as a parked
proposal until the feature lands or gets formally rejected.
220/220 example tests + `zig build test` green.
Both repros emit their target diagnostics cleanly today (verified
2026-05-28 against HEAD):
- `issue-0033` → "no visible xx conversion from 's64' to 'Wrap'
— impl exists in another module but is not imported". Catches
the case where an `impl Into(X) for Y` is registered globally
via one module's import chain but is NOT transitively imported
by the file containing the `xx` site.
- `issue-0034` → "duplicate xx conversion from 's64' to 'Wrap':
impls in <a> and <b>". Catches two impls covering the same
(Source, Target) pair both reachable from a single `xx` site.
Renamed to focused feature names:
- `issue-0033*` → `179-impl-visibility*` (4 files: main + impl +
types + user).
- `issue-0034*` → `180-impl-duplicate*` (4 files: main + impl-a +
impl-b + types).
Path references inside the files updated. Comment headers tightened
to feature-focused (drop issue-NNNN provenance — that's in git
history now). Expected `.txt` / `.exit` files captured against the
full diagnostic text and exit code 1.
The `issue-*` namespace in `examples/` now shrinks to the literal
list of UNRESOLVED bug repros. 218/218.
`examples/178-any-to-string-optional.sx` prints a struct whose
three fields are `?s64` / `?string` / `?bool`, in both Some and
None form. The struct-print path goes through `field_value(s, i)
-> Any` and then `any_to_string(Any)`. Today: `any_to_string`
has no `case optional:` arm and `resolveTypeCategoryTags` has no
"optional" category — every optional field falls through to the
`<?>` default. Expected output captures the working post-fix
form (`a: 42`, `b: hi`, `c: true` for Some; `null` across the
board for None).
The next commit adds `optional_to_string` + `case optional:` to
std and "optional" to `resolveTypeCategoryTags`. Variadic
auto-unwrap (`packVariadicCallArgs`) keeps printing direct
`print(opt)` calls correctly today; this fix closes the gap for
struct fields, slice elements, and anywhere else an optional
flows through Any.
`examples/177-generic-into-block.sx` exercises a closure shape
(`Closure(s64, s64) -> void`) that stdlib's hand-rolled
`Into(Block)` impls don't cover. Today: the focused diagnostic
"no `Into(Block) for cl_s64_s64__void` impl — add a
per-signature `__block_invoke_<sig>` trampoline + Into impl
alongside the existing ones in modules/std/objc_block.sx, or
declare it in your own code" fires at the `xx cl : Block` site.
The next commit adds the generic
`impl Into(Block) for Closure(..$args) -> $R` to
`library/modules/std/objc_block.sx` (wiring `#insert
build_block_convert($args, $R)` from step 5.1.B) plus the
lowering plumbing needed to make pack + single-type `$` refs
work inside the impl's monomorphisation. The test then flips
green — the per-shape trampoline emitted by build_block_convert
ferries (10, 20) through to the sx closure and the side-effect
stores land in g_a / g_b.
Step 5.1.A of the FFI plan (variadic heterogeneous type packs →
generic `Into(Block)` impl). The eventual step-5.2 impl body will
read `#insert build_block_convert($args, $R);` to emit a per-shape
`__invoke` `callconv(.c)` trampoline + Block literal. 5.1.A pins
the builder's expected output verbatim across three void-returning
pack shapes (0, 1, 2 args) plus one non-void shape (`f64 -> s32`)
that exercises the `return typed_fn(...)` branch.
Today: 4× "unresolved 'build_block_convert'" diagnostics — the
builder isn't in stdlib yet. The next commit adds it to
`library/modules/std/objc_block.sx` and the test flips green.
The per-position type names in the emitted source come from
`type_name(args[i])`; the slice itself is `[]Type` flowing through
the new-form variadic + bare-`$args` path that the recent
issues-0048/0049/0050 fixes unblocked.
A generic fn (with `$T: Type` type params) called from inside a
pack-fn mono inherits the outer pack maps during its OWN body
lowering. Same root cause as issue-0048 — the lowering helper
doesn't save/null `pack_arg_nodes` / `pack_param_count` /
`pack_arg_types` — but on the generic-mono path
(`monomorphizeFunction`, ~line 8718) rather than
`lazyLowerFunction`.
`examples/175-generic-fn-pack-state-leak.sx` calls
`build(args: []Type, $ret: Type)` from a four-shape pack-fn. The
expected output is `len=0 / 1 / 2 / 4`; today's run reports
`len=0` for every shape because `build__void` was first
monomorphised under `probe()`'s mono (N=0) and `args.len` got
constant-folded to 0 inside the cached body. The next commit
adds the same isolation pattern to `monomorphizeFunction`.
Step 5 of the FFI plan (generic `Into(Block)` impl) needs the
`build_block_convert(args: []Type, $ret: Type) -> string` builder,
which trips this leak directly.
Stdlib:
- `format` / `print` in std.sx — both move from `args: ..Any` to
`..args: []Any`. The post-issue-0049 lowering makes this safe
across module boundaries.
- `open` in fs.sx — `args: ..s32` → `..args: []s32`. Foreign
C-variadic semantics are preserved (the trailing `, ...` lands
in the generated `declare` regardless of which surface form is
used).
Examples:
- `19-varargs.sx` — `sum` / `print_all` migrated.
- `20-any-varargs.sx` — `print_any` / `count` migrated.
- `50-smoke.sx` — `typed_sum` migrated.
- `120-interp-variadic-any.sx` — comment-only update referencing
the new form.
- `ffi-foreign-cvariadic.sx` — three C-variadic foreign decls
migrated; header comment refreshed.
Suite stays at 214/214. The legacy `name: ..T` surface form is
still accepted by the parser; rejection follows in a later commit
once specs.md catches up.
Migrating stdlib's `path_join` to the new variadic syntax
(`(..parts: []string) -> string`) surfaces a latent compiler bug:
`resolveParamType` and `packVariadicCallArgs` treat the new-form
declaration the same as the legacy `parts: ..string` and wrap the
element type in `sliceOf` regardless of whether it already is one.
The new form's `[]string` becomes `[][]string`; the call-site
marshal pack emits `[N x string]` (correct) but the callee stores
its slice param into a `[]([]string)`-typed slot. The shape
mismatch propagates as null/undef Refs that crash
`LLVMBuildExtractValue` inside `emitStrCmp` during emission.
`examples/121-ios-sim-bundle.sx` (existing) and the new focused
`examples/174-new-form-variadic-cross-module.sx` both fail today
with the segfault. The next commit fixes `resolveParamType` +
`packVariadicCallArgs` so both flip green. Stdlib's `format` /
`print` / `open` and the example fixtures stay on the legacy form
in this commit — they migrate in the follow-up cleanup commit.
Bare `$args` evaluated inside a pack-fn body has the right `.len` /
per-element types inline, but the moment the same slice is passed
as an argument to another function, the callee silently reads
length 0 and every element comes back as undef.
Cause (per issue file): `lazyLowerFunction` saves/restores builder
state but not `pack_arg_nodes` / `pack_param_count` /
`pack_arg_types` / `inline_return_target`. When a regular fn like
`describe(args: []Any)` is lazily lowered from inside a pack-fn
mono, the outer pack maps are still active; `lowerFieldAccess`'s
`<pack_name>.len` intercept fires on `describe`'s same-named param
and bakes the outer mono's arity as a constant into describe's IR.
Every subsequent shape's call to describe returns that constant.
`examples/173-pack-bare-args-cross-call.sx` exercises four shapes
(0, 1, 3, 5 elements) through the same `describe(args: []Any)`
walker. The expected output holds the per-position type names
(`[s64]`, `[s64, string, bool]`, etc); today's diff fails — the
walker reads `args.len = 0` for every shape and returns `[]`. The
next commit fixes `lazyLowerFunction`.
Step 4A final-slice's smoke test. Exercises the FULL surface
step 5's generic Into(Block) impl needs to operate:
1. A pack-fn binds $args (whole pack as []Type).
2. The body walks `list := $args` at INTERP time.
3. Per position, calls `type_name(list[i])` — the dynamic
form that emits `callBuiltin(.type_name, ...)` at lower
time, dispatched at interp time to read the runtime
Value.type_tag and return the concrete type name.
`examples/172-pack-builder-smoke.sx` exercises four call
shapes via #run:
describe() → []
describe(42) → [s64]
describe(42, "hi") → [s64, string]
describe(true, 3.14, "x", 99) → [bool, f64, string, s64]
Each call shape builds its own [N x Any] slice of .type_tag
values at lowering time, the interp walks the slice, and the
per-element type names come out kind-honestly.
212/212 example tests + zig build test green.
Fix for the silent .s64 fall-through in `type_name(<dynamic-arg>)`.
`tryLowerReflectionCall` now splits on `isStaticTypeArg(node)`:
- Static (type_expr / identifier / pack_index_type_expr / pointer
/ array / slice / optional / many_pointer / function_type_expr
/ tuple_literal / call) → fold to const_string at lower time
(today's fast path).
- Dynamic (index_expr, field_access, runtime locals, anything
else) → emit `callBuiltin(.type_name, [arg_ref])`. The interp's
arm (commit 9600ba5) reads the runtime `.type_tag` Value and
returns the per-position name.
`isStaticTypeArg(node)` is a new helper mirroring the explicit
arms of `resolveTypeArg`. Lives alongside resolveTypeArg in
lower.zig; documented to track shape changes together.
emit_llvm: the comptime reflection builtins (`type_name`,
`type_eq`, `has_impl`) now emit a silent undef-i64 placeholder.
Same reasoning as 4A.bare.1.B's relaxation of const_type's
emit_llvm arm: the JIT compiles the containing fn module-wide
even if main never calls it, so emit-time noise here is just
dead-from-main's-perspective code. Real misuse — passing a non-
Type value to one of these — is caught by the interp arm's
`asTypeId orelse bailDetail`.
`examples/171-pack-dynamic-type-name.sx` flips from "s64s64"
(silent .s64 fold per element) to "s64string" (per-position
correct via interp arm). Test runs `walk(42, "hi")` at `#run`
time so the dynamic path executes in the interp.
211/211 example tests + zig build test green.
Step 4A final follow-up's lock-in. `type_name(<arg>)` where
<arg> is NOT a statically resolvable type expression (e.g.
`list[i]` indexing into a `$args`-derived `[]Type` slice)
silently folds to "s64" today because `resolveTypeArg`'s
index_expr fall-through returns `.s64` (the catch-all `else =>
.s64` at the bottom of the switch).
This is exactly the kind of silent unimplemented arm the
project's REJECTED PATTERNS section forbids — the user gets
"s64" for every element of an arbitrary pack, not the per-
position concrete type they expect.
`examples/171-pack-dynamic-type-name.sx` exercises a builder-
shaped fn: walks `$args` via runtime indexing, calls
`type_name(list[i])` per position, concatenates the results.
For `walk(42, "hi")` the expected output is "s64string".
Today's output is "s64s64" — the silent fold strikes twice.
Cadence shape 2: expected output is the WORKING shape; today's
diff fails. Next commit teaches `tryLowerReflectionCall` to
detect "arg not statically resolvable" and emit a builtin_call
to `.type_name` so the interp's runtime arm (wired in commit
9600ba5, M5.A.next.4.1) handles the dynamic case.
210/210 + 1 expected-failing = 211 total. zig build test green.
Step 4A final slice's lock-in. `$args` (whole pack) as a bare
expression should evaluate to a comptime `[]Type` slice value
— the whole pack passed through as data so builder fns can
walk it.
Today's parser arm (commit fd03b58, M5.A.next.4.3) requires
the `[<int_literal>]` form: bare `$<pack_name>` hits the
focused "expected '[' after '$<pack_name>'" diagnostic I added
when wiring the indexed access.
`examples/170-pack-bare-value.sx` exercises four call shapes
of a pack-fn whose body binds `list := $args` then returns
`list.len`. Expected output (post-fix) is "0/1/3/4" per call.
Today the parser rejection diff makes the test fail —
209/209 + 1 expected-failing = 210 total.
Cadence shape 2: expected output is the WORKING shape; pre-fix
the parser-error diff fails. Next commit lands the parser
extension + AST node + lowering and the test flips green.
Final slice of the .type_tag activation. Sx code can now
construct Type values through the `$<pack>[<int_literal>]`
syntax in expression position. Lowering emits the new
`const_type(TypeId)` opcode; the interp materialises
`Value.type_tag(TypeId)`; reflection intrinsics + cmp_eq
read it kind-honestly.
Plumbing:
- src/parser.zig: `parsePrimary` accepts `$<ident>[<int_literal>]`
at the front of every expression. Emits a `pack_index_type_expr`
AST node — same node already used in TYPE positions in step 3,
now extended to expression positions.
- src/ir/lower.zig: two places teach the new node.
- `lowerExpr` arm: looks up `pack_arg_types[name][index]`, emits
`builder.constType(arg_tys[index])`. OOB / no-binding paths
emit a focused diagnostic + a `constType(.void)` placeholder
(loud failure preserves silent-error budget).
- `resolveTypeArg` arm: the same lookup, but returns the
TypeId directly. Used by the lower-time fast paths in
`tryLowerReflectionCall` + `tryConstBoolCondition` so
`type_name($args[0])`, `type_eq($args[0], s64)`, and
`has_impl(...)` all see the bound TypeId rather than
falling through to the `.s64` default that the silent-arm
rule forbids.
The two arms ensure both runtime AND compile-time paths use
the same source-of-truth (`pack_arg_types`), so per-mono
dispatch via `inline if type_eq($args[0], s64) { ... }` folds
at compile time as expected.
`examples/169-pack-value-dispatch.sx` exercises both shapes:
- `type_name($args[0])` returns the per-mono concrete type
name ("s64", "string", "f64").
- `inline if type_eq($args[0], s64) { ... }` ladder dispatches
per-mono ("got s64", "got string", "got bool", "got other").
209/209 example tests + `zig build test` green.
What's now possible end-to-end:
show :: (..$args) -> string => type_name($args[0]);
show(42) // "s64"
show("hi") // "string"
describe :: (..$args) -> string {
inline if type_eq($args[0], s64) { return "got s64"; }
...
}
The "by the book" activation is complete:
- foundation (const_type opcode, interp variant, helpers) — 4.0
- interp reflection arms (type_name / type_eq / has_impl) — 4.1
- box_any/display audit + bitcast guard — 4.2
- source-language construction via $args[$i] — 4.3
Step 5 (generic Into(Block) impl in stdlib) is now fully
unblocked — its trampoline body can interpolate per-mono types
both in type positions AND in expression positions.
Step 3 second slice. Adds two reflection builtins used by
pack-fn bodies to branch on type identity / protocol
membership at compile time. type_name already existed
(lower.zig:8693); reused as-is.
type_eq(T1, T2) -> bool structural TypeId equality
has_impl(P, T) -> bool T has a reachable impl for P
Both are wired through `tryConstBoolCondition` so the inline-if
ladder folds them at lower time — `inline if type_eq(...)` /
`inline if has_impl(...)` collapse to a single branch with no
runtime instructions, perfect for guard-based dispatch inside
pack-fn bodies.
`has_impl`'s protocol arg accepts two shapes:
- plain protocol name: `has_impl(Allocator, CAllocator)` →
walks `protocol_thunk_map["Allocator\x00CAllocator"]`.
- parameterised call: `has_impl(Into(Block), s64)` →
builds the param_impl_map key `"Into\x00Block\x00s64"`
and checks containment. The protocol type-args resolve
through `resolveTypeArg` so type aliases, generics, and
pack-indexed types all work as protocol args.
`computeHasImpl` is the shared implementation between the
runtime builtin path and the `tryConstBoolCondition` fast
path so both branches stay in sync.
`examples/168-pack-reflection-intrinsics.sx` exercises every
shape:
- type_name for primitive types.
- type_eq with both equal + unequal cases, including pointer
types (s64 vs *s64).
- inline-if folding type_eq.
- has_impl with a real plain-protocol impl
(Allocator/CAllocator → true; Allocator/s64 → false).
- has_impl with a user-defined parameterised protocol
(Wrap(s64)/s32 → true; mismatched target args → false).
208/208 example tests + `zig build test` green.
Caveat: plain-protocol has_impl uses `protocol_thunk_map`
which is lazily populated when an `xx` cast or protocol
dispatch creates the thunks. For a static check before any
dispatch, that could false-negative. Allocator/CAllocator
works in 168 because stdlib's startup uses CAllocator through
the Allocator protocol — the thunks already exist by the time
has_impl runs. A more robust static check (walk fn_ast_map for
"<T_name>.<method>" entries against the protocol's method
list) is deferred to a follow-up if needed.
LSP "undefined variable" warnings on type names in expression
position (s64, *s64, Wrap(s64), etc. passed to type_eq /
has_impl) are cosmetic — sema doesn't know these intrinsics
accept types as args. Tracked separately.
Adds `resolveFunctionTypeWithBindings` so `function_type_expr`
in a binding-aware context — local var annotations, return
types, nested type expressions — recursively resolves through
the active pack bindings. Without this, the fall-through to
`type_bridge.resolveAstType` lost pack context and the new
`pack_index_type_expr` arm spammed the "outside pack-aware
context" diagnostic (the function still worked by accident
thanks to the `.s64` fallback).
Plumbing:
- `resolveTypeWithBindings` adds a `function_type_expr` case
in both the bindings-active branch and the fallthrough
switch (the same shape as `closure_type_expr`).
- `resolveFunctionTypeWithBindings` recursively resolves each
param + return type with bindings, then calls
`functionTypeCC` with the AST's calling convention.
`examples/167-pack-type-fnptr.sx` exercises the pattern step
5's trampoline needs:
fp : (*void, $args[0]) -> $args[1] = double_s64;
return fp(null, args[0]);
Output: 14 (= 7*2 via the typed fn-pointer).
207/207 example tests + `zig build test` green.
Step 3 first slice. `$<pack>[<int_literal>]` now parses in
every type position and resolves against the active pack
binding (`pack_arg_types` map set up by `monomorphizePackFn`).
Plumbing:
- src/ast.zig: new `PackIndexTypeExpr { pack_name, index }`
AST node + `pack_index_type_expr` variant in `Data`.
- src/parser.zig: in `parseTypeExpr`'s `$<ident>` arm, peek
for `[`. If found, parse a non-negative `int_literal` index
followed by `]` and emit a `pack_index_type_expr` node.
Plain `$T` / `$T/Eq` paths unchanged.
- src/ir/lower.zig::resolveTypeWithBindings: handles
`pack_index_type_expr` first — looks up the pack name in
`pack_arg_types`, returns `arg_tys[index]` when in range.
OOB and "no active pack binding" cases emit focused
diagnostics at the node span.
- src/ir/type_bridge.zig::resolveAstType: handles the same
node but falls back to `.s64` with a stderr note — the bare
type_bridge has no access to lowering state. Pack-aware
callers route through `resolveTypeWithBindings`.
- src/sema.zig: adds `pack_index_type_expr` to the no-op
arms in `analyzeNode` and `findNodeAtOffset` so the sema
pass doesn't reject the new variant.
Tests:
- examples/165-pack-type-position.sx (lock-in from 69dcee8)
flips from parse error to "42 first". Exercises both a
return-type position (-> $args[0]) AND a local-var
annotation (second : $args[1] = args[1]); two
heterogeneous call shapes confirm distinct monos pick
distinct concrete types per pack index.
- examples/166-pack-type-position-three.sx — three-element
pack with $args[2] (third element) as return type. Three
call shapes: (s64,s64,string), (bool,f64,s64),
(string,string,bool). Prints "third 99 false".
Out of scope (deferred):
- $args[$i] where $i is a comptime-bound expression (only
literal int supported in this slice).
- $args[$i] in fn-pointer type LITERALS (works for named
decls but nested fn type expressions need an audit).
- $args[$i] in struct field types.
206/206 example tests + `zig build test` green.
Step 3 of the variadic heterogeneous type packs feature.
`$args[$i]` (with `$i` a literal integer for the first slice)
should resolve to the i-th element type of the active pack
binding in every type position: return types, param types,
local var annotations, fn-pointer type literals, struct fields.
Today the parser hits "expected '{'" at the `$args[<lit>]`
token because the `$<ident>` arm in `parseTypeExpr` only
recognises plain generic names (`$T`, `$T/Eq/Hashable`).
After `<ident>`, an opening `[` is unexpected.
`examples/165-pack-type-position.sx` exercises two type
positions per mono — a return type `-> $args[0]` AND a local
var annotation `second : $args[1] = args[1]` — so the parser
change must cover more than the trailing return arrow. Two
call shapes (`swap_take(42, "ignored")` and `swap_take("first",
99)`) confirm heterogeneous monos pick distinct concrete
types per position.
Cadence shape 2: the expected output is the WORKING output
("42 first"); pre-fix the diff vs the parser-error output
fails. Next commit lands the parser + resolver changes and the
test flips green.
204/204 + 1 expected-failing = 205 total. `zig build test`
green.
Lock-in for issue-0046. The test file expects the WORKING
output ("inside" / "n=42") — pre-fix the interp panics
non-deterministically at `storeAtRawPtr` (null pointer store)
because `createComptimeFunction` does not save/restore the
outer `lowerComptimeCall`'s `inline_return_target` state; the
wrapper fn built for the nested `print` body inherits a slot
belonging to a different basic block.
Cadence rule shape 2: expected-failing test, the next commit
turns it green. Today the suite shows 1 failure (issue-0046);
post-fix it returns to all green.
The thread ID + hex addresses in the panic output are non-
deterministic so locking in the broken shape directly would
be flaky — comparing actual panic vs expected-working still
diffs as FAIL pre-fix, no need to snapshot the panic.
The pack-fn face of issue-0046 was fixed incidentally by step
2b (mono path bypasses the inline-return-slot setup that
leaked into nested comptime calls). Plain `($x: s32)` comptime
fns stay on the inline path and still need this fix.
Follow-up #1 from step 2b: pack-fns that mix a non-pack
comptime param with the trailing pack (e.g. `tagged($tag: s32,
..$args)`). Today's `isPackFn` requires the pack to be the
ONLY comptime param; mixed shapes fall through to the inline
`lowerComptimeCall` path. That path adds non-string comptime
params to `comptime_param_nodes` for #insert substitution but
does NOT bind them as runtime locals, so the body's bare
`tag` reference hits "unresolved 'tag'" at the call site.
Next commit:
- Relax `isPackFn` to "exactly one trailing pack + any number
of non-pack comptime params" so the mono path takes over.
- Fold comptime VALUES into the mangled name (`tagged(7, ...)`
and `tagged(9, ...)` get distinct monos so each body sees
its own comptime constants).
- Bind comptime args as both `comptime_param_nodes` (for
#insert substitution) AND runtime locals (for bare-name
references). String literals stay as string locals;
int/bool/float literals become typed locals of the
appropriate primitive type.
This is the load-bearing prerequisite for step 6 (stdlib
`print`/`format` refactor to `(\$fmt, ..\$args)`) — without
mixed-mode mono support, stdlib stays on the inline path
forever.
203/203 example tests + `zig build test` green (the lock-in
captures the wrong-shape diagnostic as the snapshot to flip).
Lock-ins for follow-ups #3 (bare `args` reference) and #4
(`args[<runtime_int>]`) from step 2b. Both share the same root
cause: the pack-mono does not materialise an `[]Any` slice
value for the pack name, so any body that needs `args` as a
value at runtime fails.
`examples/162-pack-bare-args.sx` — pack-fn body forwards `args`
to a `[]Any`-typed helper. Today: "unresolved 'args' (in
... fn forward__pack_s64_string_f64)".
`examples/163-pack-runtime-index.sx` — pack-fn body indexes
`args[i]` with a runtime `i`. Today: LLVM verifier crash —
"GEP base pointer is not a vector or a vector of pointers" —
because `args` resolves to a junk Ref via the scope-lookup
fall-through, and the slice-indexing path emits a GEP off
that.
Next commit materialises an `[]Any` slice on demand inside the
mono: each pack param is boxed into Any, stored in a stack
[N x Any] array, and the slice {data_ptr, len} is bound to the
pack name. `args` then resolves as a runtime value the same way
the pre-2b inline path used to. `args[i]` runtime indexing goes
through the standard slice index path; element type is `Any`
(lossy on per-position types — inherent to runtime indexing
into a heterogeneous pack).
202/202 example tests + `zig build test` green.
Two follow-on fixes for follow-up #2 (generic pack-fn return).
(1) `pack_arg_types` — a new type-only pack binding consulted by
`inferExprType` for `<pack_name>[<int_literal>]`. The earlier
`pack_arg_nodes`-via-synthesized-idents path lost the type
during return-type inference because the synthesized idents
("__pack_args_0" etc.) only resolve once the mono scope is set
up — but the inference runs BEFORE scope setup. Now
`monomorphizePackFn` installs `pack_arg_types[<pack>] =
arg_types` alongside the existing nodes/count maps, and
`inferExprType` consults it directly.
`foo(..$args) -> $R => args[2]` called as `foo(42, 3.2, "hello")`
now correctly returns "hello" (string) — the third element-
typed pick threads through inference to the mono ret_ty.
(2) `diagPackIndexOOB` — focused diagnostic for `args[<lit>]`
where the literal exceeds the pack arity. Pre-fix the
substitution returned null and the standard slice-indexing
fall-through emitted "unresolved args" — burying the real
cause. Now: "pack index 2 out of bounds: 'args' has 1
element" at the index span.
Tests:
- `examples/160-pack-hetero-ret.sx` — generic `$R` with non-
zeroth heterogeneous pick (returns "hello").
- `examples/161-pack-index-oob.sx` — call passes 1 arg but
body indexes args[2]; locks in the OOB diagnostic shape.
200/200 example tests + `zig build test` green.
Follow-up #2 from step 2b: pack-fns with a generic return type
(`(..\$args) -> \$R`). Today's `monomorphizePackFn` calls
`resolveReturnType` which sees `\$R` as a generic name and
returns an opaque struct TypeId. The mono's ret_ty is wrong
and the value silently coerces to 0.
`examples/159-pack-generic-ret.sx` pins this: `first(42)` and
`first(99)` both return `0` instead of the call arg. The lock-in
captures the wrong output as the snapshot to flip.
Next commit infers the ret type from the body's tail expression
(arrow form) or the first explicit `return X;` (block form),
then builds the mono signature against that concrete type.
198/198 example tests + \`zig build test\` green.
Pack-fns (`isPackFn(fd) == true` — last param `is_variadic AND
is_comptime`, no other comptime params) now emit ONE
monomorphised function per unique call-site signature. Repeat
calls with the same arg-type tuple share the mono; distinct
shapes get distinct symbols. Pre-2b each call inlined a fresh
body copy into the caller's basic block; IR size grew linearly
in call sites.
Plumbing in `src/ir/lower.zig`:
- `isPackFn(fd)` — true when the only comptime param is a
trailing pack. Mixed `($fmt, ..$args)` shapes stay on the
inline `lowerComptimeCall` path (different substitution
mechanism for the comptime non-pack param; deferred).
- `lowerPackFnCall(fd, call_node)`:
- Builds a mangled name `<fn_name>__pack__<arg_types>` from
call-site `inferExprType` results. Distinct shapes get
distinct symbols.
- Cache-checks `lowered_functions`; calls
`monomorphizePackFn` on miss.
- Lowers call args, then re-fetches the func pointer (the
fetch BEFORE arg lowering would invalidate after any
transitively-triggered module.functions.items realloc),
prepends ctx if needed, coerces, emits direct call.
- `monomorphizePackFn(fd, mangled, arg_types)`:
- Mirrors `monomorphizeFunction` for the standard fn build:
save state, build param list (ctx + fixed prefix + N pack
params with synthesised names `__pack_<name>_<i>`),
`beginFunction`, entry block, bind params to scope.
- Installs `pack_arg_nodes[<name>]` with synthesised AST
identifier nodes pointing at the pack-param slots so the
body's `args[<int_literal>]` substitutes through the
existing 2a.B mechanism — substitution resolves to the
mono's own param slot loads.
- Installs `pack_param_count[<name>] = N` so the body's
`args.len` resolves to a compile-time constant via a new
intercept in `lowerFieldAccess` (and the parallel arm in
`inferExprType`).
- Lowers the body with `inline_return_target = null` so
`return X;` emits a real `ret X` instead of the inline-slot
routing — the mono is a real fn now.
- Routed at three call sites: each `if (hasComptimeParams(fd))
{ return self.lowerComptimeCall(...); }` now first checks
`isPackFn(fd)` and routes to `lowerPackFnCall` when true.
Lifetime gotcha caught and fixed: `params.items` is stored by
reference in `Function.init` (no copy), so the local
`ArrayList(Function.Param)` must NOT be deinit'd in
`monomorphizePackFn` — matches the leak convention already used
by `monomorphizeFunction`.
`examples/158-pack-mono-dedup.sx` confirms the dedup
end-to-end: `count(), count(1), count(2), count(1,2,3),
count("x", true)` produces `0 1 1 3 2` at runtime AND emits
exactly 4 monos in IR (`count__pack`, `count__pack_s64`,
`count__pack_s64_s64_s64`, `count__pack_string_bool`) — the
two s64 calls share. `args.len` resolves to the comptime
constant N inside each mono.
`examples/156-pack-typed-index.sx` and
`examples/157-pack-if-return.sx` continue to pass unchanged.
Out of scope:
- Mixed `$fmt + ..$args` shapes (stays on inline path).
- Generic `$R` return types (concrete returns only).
- Bare `args` reference (passing the slice as a whole).
- `args[<runtime_int>]` (non-literal index).
197/197 example tests + `zig build test` green.
Follow-up to issue-0045's fix (commit 9e78790). The fix routes
inline-comptime-body `return X;` into a result slot but sets
`block_terminated = true` after the inline return — and that
flag leaks past the enclosing `if`'s merge block.
Body shape:
maybe :: (..$args) -> s64 {
if args.len > 0 { return 42; }
return -1;
}
For `maybe()` (zero call-args), the false-condition path skips
the then-branch's `return 42;` and should fall through to
`return -1;`. Today's flow:
- Then-branch's `return 42;` stores 42 to slot and sets
block_terminated = true.
- if lowering switches to merge_bb. block_terminated stays
true (never reset across the if/merge boundary).
- lowerBlockValue's loop sees block_terminated and returns
null without processing the trailing `return -1;`.
- lowerComptimeCall loads slot — slot was never written on
the false-condition path → garbage (8354116000 on this
machine; stable across runs).
`maybe(99)` works because the cond is true; the then-branch's
store wins.
Next commit reshapes the inline-return mechanism to use a
dedicated "return-done" basic block: each inline `return X;`
stores to slot and branches to ret_done; after the body
lowers, lowerComptimeCall switches to ret_done and loads. The
basic block CFG carries the control-flow termination — no
need for the leaking `block_terminated` flag.
196/196 example tests + `zig build test` green (the new test
captures the wrong value as the snapshot to flip).
Step 2 of the variadic heterogeneous type packs feature: typed
runtime indexing (`args[$i]` at comptime-known `$i`). Today's
pack-fn body lowers `args[i]` through the `[]Any` slice path —
the static type returned is `Any`, so any downstream field
access / typed-coercion / further indexing fails the moment it
needs more than primitive auto-unboxing.
`examples/156-pack-typed-index.sx` pins the simplest visible
failure: `args[0].x` on a struct-typed call arg trips
"field 'x' not found on type 'Any'" at the field-access site
because AST-level type inference for `args[0]` returns Any.
Next commit teaches `lowerIndexExpr` (and `inferExprType` for
the same shape) to detect an index_expr whose base is a
pack-name binding from the enclosing comptime call AND whose
index is a comptime int literal — substitutes the i-th
call-site arg's lowered value directly, propagating the call
arg's concrete type through field access, typed assignments,
and further indexing. The `[]Any` slice path stays as the
runtime-indexed fallback for `args[i]` where `i` is not a
comptime constant.
195/195 example tests + `zig build test` green.
Filed `issues/0045-pack-fn-call-llvm-verifier-failure.md`.
Surfaced by probing step 2 territory of the variadic
heterogeneous type packs feature: any `..$args` fn whose body
is a block containing `return X;` (or any comptime fn with a
non-void return, comptime params, and explicit `return` in a
block body) trips LLVM's "Terminator found in the middle of a
basic block" verifier.
`lowerComptimeCall` inlines the body's statements directly into
the caller's LLVM function. `lowerReturn` then emits a `ret`
into the caller's basic block — but the caller still has
trailing instructions, hence the verifier failure.
`examples/issue-0045.sx` reproduces the crash with the minimum
pack-fn shape (`foo :: (..$args) -> s64 { return 42; }`). Same
shape with a plain comptime param (`($x: s32) -> s64 { return
42; }`) reproduces identically, so the bug is broader than
packs. Arrow-form bodies (`=> 42`) work today because they have
no `return` statement.
Next commit teaches `lowerComptimeCall` to allocate a result
slot when the body contains a `return`, and reroutes
`lowerReturn` to store into that slot + flag the block as
terminated so the inliner picks up the value.
Step 1d lock-in test pinning today's matching behaviour.
`registerParamImpl` records every impl in `param_impl_map` keyed
by `"Proto\x00<arg_mangled>\x00<src_mangled>"`. For a pack impl
`Into(Block) for Closure(..$args) -> $R` the key contains the
pack-shaped closure's mangle (interns with `pack_start = Some(0)`
after 1c.B). At the `xx cl : *Block` site the lookup mangles the
concrete `Closure(s32, bool) -> bool` source and finds nothing —
the existing focused diagnostic fires:
no `Into(Block) for cl_s32_bool__bool` impl — add a per-signature
`__block_invoke_<sig>` trampoline + Into impl alongside the
existing ones in modules/std/objc_block.sx, or declare it in
your own code
The pack impl is reachable in the file but never considered.
Next commit (1d.B):
- New `param_impl_pack_map` keyed by `"Proto\x00<arg_mangled>"`
(no src) — populated by `registerParamImpl` when the source
is pack-shaped.
- `tryUserConversion` walks the pack map on concrete-key miss.
Pack shape matches when the impl's fixed prefix equals the
source's matching prefix; the remainder binds to `$args` and
the source's return type binds to `$R`. Concrete impls win
over pack impls (specificity).
- `resolveTypeWithBindings` learns the closure_type_expr path
so the impl body's `self: Closure(..$args) -> $R` substitutes
to the concrete source closure during monomorphisation.
The `Closure(s32, bool) -> bool` shape is not covered by stdlib
or 96-block-multi-arg's hand-rolled impls, so the pack impl is
the only candidate post-1d.B.
193/193 example tests + `zig build test` green.
Next slice of the variadic heterogeneous type packs (`..$args`)
feature: type-system representation. Per the FFI cadence rule, this
commit locks in the parser-rejection behavior so the next commit's
type-rep extension surfaces as a behavior shift.
examples/154-pack-type-rep.sx uses `..$args` inside a `Closure(...)`
type expression — the pack-shape spelling used by impl headers like
`impl Into(Block) for Closure(..$args) -> $R`. Today's parser
recognizes `..$args` only at the parameter-list site (1b);
`parseTypeExpr`'s `Closure(...)` arm calls `parseTypeExpr` per
position and hits "expected type name" at the `..` token. Snapshot
captures the rejection at line 18, column 26.
Next commit (1c.B):
- Parser: `parseTypeExpr` Closure arm accepts `..$args` as the
trailing pack marker. AST gets a `pack_name: ?[]const u8` (or
equivalent) field on `ClosureTypeExpr`.
- types.zig: `FunctionInfo` / `ClosureInfo` gain `pack_start: ?u32`
so the pack shape is distinct from any concrete arity in the
type table. Hash/eql updated.
- type_bridge: `resolveClosureType` threads pack_start through.
- 154 flips green.
192/192 example tests + `zig build test` green.
Extends parseParams in src/parser.zig:1558 to recognize a leading
`..` before the optional `$` sigil and the parameter name. The
old `args: ..T` form (variadic marker after the colon) still
works — both paths set the same `is_variadic` flag.
A pack declaration `..$args` parses as:
- `is_variadic = true` (from the leading `..`)
- `is_comptime = true` (from the `$` sigil)
- `type_expr = inferred_type` (no `:` annotation)
The no-colon branch now propagates `is_variadic` and `is_comptime`
onto the Param struct so later slices (type rep, impl matching,
monomorphisation) can read both flags from the parsed AST without
re-deriving from token sequence.
`examples/150-pack-parse.sx` flips from rejecting-with-error to
positive parse smoke. No semantic effect yet — `foo` is declared
but never instantiated.
191/191 example tests + `zig build test` green.
First slice of the `..$args` (variadic heterogeneous type pack)
feature. Locks in the current parser-rejection behavior so the
next commit's parser extension shows up as a behavior shift.
`examples/150-pack-parse.sx` declares `foo :: (..$args) -> s64`.
Today's parser hits `..` where it expects a parameter name
(parseParams in src/parser.zig:1558 only handles `..` inside the
type position after a colon) and emits "expected parameter name".
Expected output captures this rejection.
Per FFI cadence rule, this is the "test fails today, passes after
next commit's parser change" pair.
Pack feature plan saved at
~/.claude/plans/lets-see-options-for-merry-dijkstra.md ("Variadic
heterogeneous type packs" section). Motivates replacing the
hand-rolled per-signature `Into(Block)` impls with one generic
`impl Into(Block) for Closure(..$args) -> $R`; also unlocks
compile-time arity/type errors for `print`/`format`.
191/191 example tests + `zig build test` green.
Reconsidered the M5.A.2 cleanup. The compiler-synthesised trampoline
path was hidden behaviour — a user reading their code couldn't tell
how `xx my_closure : Block` worked without reading lower.zig. That's
exactly the kind of magic sx's design has been pushing against.
New design (strict mode):
1. Stdlib's modules/std/objc_block.sx hand-rolls
`__block_invoke_void` + `Into(Block) for Closure() -> void` and
the same pair for `Closure(bool) -> void` (restored from M5.A.2).
These are readable reference implementations of the bridge ABI.
2. The compiler intercept fires NO synthesis — instead, when
`tryUserConversion` can't find a reachable `Into(Block)` impl for
the closure's signature, it emits a focused diagnostic:
"no `Into(Block) for <Closure-sig>` impl — add a per-signature
`__block_invoke_<sig>` trampoline + Into impl alongside the
existing ones in modules/std/objc_block.sx, or declare it in
your own code"
3. Per-signature declarations live in stdlib (for common signatures)
or in user code (for app-specific ones). 96-objc-block-multi-arg
now demonstrates the user-side pattern in-file — it declares its
own `__block_invoke_void_s32_p` + `Into(Block) for Closure(s32,
*void) -> void` impl alongside its main().
Net effect:
- Every block bridge is source-visible. No hidden compiler magic.
- Users see exactly how the Apple ABI shape is constructed in sx
source — stdlib serves as the reference implementation.
- Compiler enforces the discipline: missing impl → clear diagnostic
pointing at the template.
- Coverage for arbitrary signatures requires conscious user opt-in,
not silent fallthrough.
Removed from lower.zig: `tryClosureToBlockConversion`,
`emitBlockInvokeTrampoline`, `mangleClosureSigForBlock`,
`mangleTypeForBlock`, and the `block_invoke_trampolines` dedup
state field. Net: the synthesis machinery is gone; only the
detection helper `isClosureToBlockCast` remains, used by the
diagnostic.
190/190 example tests pass; chess on iOS-sim green.
